For the purposes of a clearer explanation, here’s an impromptu list that I would like to recognize as some other hits and misses from 2011 – there will be some overlap with Spike TV’s awards as well as a few surprises. Here we go.
Most dissapointing sequel of 2011: Dragon Age II
Talk about wasted potential. I mean, here’s a game that had so much prowess riding behind it. (A sequel to one of the best role-playing games of this generation! Come on!) So much, in fact, that it fell flat on its face. Race no longer played a part in your origin story like it did in the first game. You never really felt like you were crafting a story about “you” in the game – just some bloke named Hawke and his crew of unlikable expendables. His origin story remained the same regardless of what class you chose and combat came down to a case of simple skill spams and fast attack combos. At least Bioware improved the inventory management sections of the game.
Best PC exclusive of 2011: The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
Not only does this game look great it also proves that the PC can still hold its own as a game machine while telling a an open-ended, mature, and thought provoking story – a story where not everything is as simple as a straight line between good vs evil.
While the main character, Geralt, exists as a result from his own origin story and previous adventures, his incarnation at the end of The Witcher 2’s events is completely dependant on the player.
There are a set number of skill points to spend through the course of the adventure and either of the two political powers you side with come with their own point of view of the same story. Replays of the adventure are not mandatory, but, if you find yourself asking “what if Geralt…” there’s more than enough to make you go back and pick that other option.
Best Wii exclusive of 2011 that is not a Zelda game: Xenoblade Chronicles
Lets face it, if it weren’t for the magic of the Internet or the boys over at Operation Rainfall, this game could have just been passed off as just another JRPG and forgotten under a mountain of everything else from that country. Having played the English version due to a trip to Europe over the summer, I can say with full confidence that this game is anything but just another JRPG.
It combines the battle, side-questing, and exploration elements of most MMORPGs with a story by Xenogears mastermind, Tetsuya Takahashi, into a bizzaro prequel/sequel that could have just as well taken place in a parallel universe.
For a console that’s undoubtedly nearing the end of its lifespan, having another swansong title NOT be a trademark Nintendo property, this is a breath of fresh air. Fans will be content with its eventual stateside release.
Best puzzle game of 2011: Portal 2
There’s not much to say about Portal 2 that hasn’t been said already. Give it a weekend rental and you’ll understand why I had enough fun with this game to include it under two award headings. It makes you think, teaches you game physics AND it takes place in a first-person camera perspective with a gun glued at the end. Shocking.
If that’s not a case for a winner I don’t know what is.
Best technical achievement of 2011: L.A. Noire
I think it’s safe to write this game off as the next level of motion capture. While the animations weren’t perfect the performances were on the money. Sure, it didn’t come out as the shining example of perfection we were anticipating but it took place in one of my favorite time periods and told a detective caper reminiscent of those nostalgic adventure games of yore. It was a very enjoyable 20-plus hour ride and picking out TV actors you’ve seen before was a real treat.

Best trilogy capper in 2011: Gears of War 3
The Gears franchise isn’t dead, that much is fact. But out of all number of 3s released this year Gears of War 3 gets the nod for topping off Marcus and Co’s story with an ending that satisfied but still left plenty of opportunities for the franchise to grow.
Most disappointing launch of 2011: 3DS
A perfect example of good things coming to patient people. The system is currently at a steal of a price and the library has grown into something formidable but who remembers the first few rocky weeks of the 3DS’s launch?
The asking price – ridiculous! The launch title offerings – laughable!
All in a handheld system that skipped out on certain features until its first major firmware update and even came with the infamous black screen of death right out of the box!
Best LOLs in a game from 2011: Portal 2
This recognition is presented in conjunction with “Best Puzzle Game.” Along with being an entertaining puzzle game Portal 2 also came with so many memorable LOLs it’s hard to pick a single favorite character.

The game from 2011 that should have been a movie: Uncharted 3
At first I was considering placing L.A. Noire in this category. Then I played Uncharted 3. This game had everything a popcorn munching action flick could ask for – diabolical villians, cheeky one-liners, and story that unraveled itself through the course of the campaign. It also begs a thought-provoking question; Why are game stories so much more effective in their own mediums while movies based off of video games leave a lot more to be desired?
The Best bad game of 2011: Dead Island
This is taken into account before installing the recent patch that supposedly fixes a lot of the game’s problems. The family oriented trailer mislead us into thinking this game was going in one direction while it snuck out the back and gave us “Who Do You Voodoo” and a cover art change in some regions. I feel like I’ve been hoodwinked by this game and you should too.